
This is a science fiction story set in the year 2157 that shows us how schools might be in future with computers playing major role in education. The story talks about children who will study through mechanical teachers and compares it with old traditional schools.
The story is set in future when books and schools as we know them might not exist anymore. Children will study through different means:
- Learning through computers – Students will use computer-based learning systems instead of traditional methods
- Virtual classroom – Not real classroom but learning happens through computer software or Internet
- Robotic teacher – Mechanical teachers that can adjust to each student’s level
- Moving e-text – Text that moves on screen instead of staying still on paper
Virtual reality means a reality created by computer software. Children today may already know about robots and can imagine what robotic teachers would be like.
The Story
Introduction – Finding the Old Book
On 17 May 2157, Margie wrote in her diary about an important discovery – Tommy had found a real book! This book was very old. Margie’s grandfather once said that when he was a little boy, his grandfather told him there was a time when all stories were printed on paper.
The children looked at the book with curiosity:
- The pages were yellow and crinkly
- The words stood still on the page instead of moving like they were supposed to on screen
- When they turned back to previous page, it had same words as before
Tommy found the book quite wasteful. He said when you finish with book, you just throw it away. But their television screen had million books on it and was good for plenty more. He wouldn’t throw away his screen.
Margie was eleven years old and hadn’t seen as many telebooks as Tommy, who was thirteen. She asked him where he found it. Tommy said he found it in his house, in the attic, without looking up because he was busy reading.
When Margie asked what the book was about, Tommy answered “School.”
Margie’s Hatred for School
Margie was scornful when she heard it was about school. She asked “School? What’s there to write about school? I hate school.”
Margie always hated school, but now she hated it more than ever because:
- The mechanical teacher had been giving her test after test in geography
- She had been doing worse and worse in the tests
- Her mother had shaken her head sorrowfully and sent for County Inspector
The County Inspector was a round little man with red face and whole box of tools with dials and wires. He smiled at Margie, gave her an apple, then took the teacher apart.
Margie had hoped he wouldn’t know how to put it together again, but he knew how all right. After an hour or so, there it was again – large and black and ugly, with big screen showing all lessons and asking questions.
The Mechanical Teacher
The part Margie hated most about her mechanical teacher was the slot where she had to put homework and test papers. She always had to write them in punch code they made her learn when she was six years old. The mechanical teacher calculated marks in no time.
After finishing inspection, the Inspector smiled and patted Margie’s head. He told her mother:
- It’s not little girl’s fault
- Geography sector was geared little too quick
- These things happen sometimes
- He has slowed it up to average ten-year level
- Overall pattern of her progress is quite satisfactory
Margie was disappointed because she had been hoping they would take teacher away altogether. They had once taken Tommy’s teacher away for nearly a month because history sector had blanked out completely.
Discussion About Old Schools
Margie asked Tommy why anyone would write about school. Tommy looked at her with very superior eyes and explained it’s not their kind of school. This is old kind of school they had hundreds and hundreds of years ago – centuries ago, he added loftily.
Margie was hurt and said she doesn’t know what kind of school they had all that time ago. She read book over his shoulder for a while and said “Anyway, they had a teacher.”
Key differences about old schools:
| Aspect | Old Schools | Future Schools (Margie’s time) |
|---|---|---|
| Teacher | Human being (a man) | Mechanical teacher |
| Location | Special building where all kids went | Right next to bedroom at home |
| Classmates | All kids from neighborhood together | Each child studied alone |
| Lessons | Same for all kids of same age | Adjusted for each child’s level |
| Homework | Given by human teacher | Put in slot for mechanical teacher |
Tommy explained that in old schools:
- The teacher was a man who told boys and girls things
- Gave them homework and asked questions
- Teachers didn’t live in the house
- They had special building and all kids went there
- All kids learned same thing if they were same age
Margie’s mother had told her that teacher has to be adjusted to fit mind of each boy and girl it teaches and each kid has to be taught differently. But Tommy said they didn’t do it that way in old times.
Margie’s School Routine
Margie’s mother called “Margie! School!” but Margie looked up and said “Not yet, Mamma.” Her mother insisted “Now!” and said it’s probably time for Tommy too.
Margie asked Tommy if she could read book some more with him after school. He said “May be” nonchalantly and walked away whistling, with dusty old book tucked beneath his arm.
Margie went into the schoolroom which was right next to her bedroom. The mechanical teacher was on and waiting for her. It was always on at same time every day except Saturday and Sunday, because her mother said little girls learned better if they learned at regular hours.
The screen was lit up with today’s lesson:
“Today’s arithmetic lesson is on addition of proper fractions. Please insert yesterday’s homework in proper slot.”
Missing the Old Days
Margie did her work with a sigh. She was thinking about old schools they had when her grandfather’s grandfather was a little boy:
- All kids from whole neighborhood came together
- Laughing and shouting in schoolyard
- Sitting together in schoolroom
- Going home together at end of day
- They learned same things, so they could help one another with homework and talk about it
- The teachers were people
The mechanical teacher was flashing on screen: “When we add fractions ½ and ¼…”
But Margie was thinking about how kids must have loved it in old days. She was thinking about the fun they had.
Thinking about the Text
Short Answer Questions
How old are Margie and Tommy?
- Margie was eleven years old
- Tommy was thirteen years old
What did Margie write in her diary?
- On page headed 17 May 2157, she wrote “Today Tommy found a real book!”
Had Margie ever seen a book before?
- No, Margie had never seen a real printed book before
- She had only seen telebooks on television screen
What things about the book did she find strange?
- The pages were yellow and crinkly
- Words stood still instead of moving like on screen
- When they turned back to previous page, it had same words as before
- It seemed wasteful because you throw it away when finished
What do you think a telebook is?
- A telebook is a book that appears on television or computer screen
- It has moving text instead of still printed words
- One screen can have million books stored on it
- It doesn’t need to be thrown away after reading
Where was Margie’s school? Did she have any classmates?
- Margie’s school was right next to her bedroom in her own house
- No, she did not have any classmates
- She studied alone with her mechanical teacher
What subjects did Margie and Tommy learn?
- Margie learned geography and arithmetic
- Tommy learned history
- They studied through their mechanical teachers
Reference to Context Questions
“I wouldn’t throw it away.”
- Tommy says these words
- ‘It’ refers to television screen that has telebooks
- It is being compared with old printed book that gets thrown away after reading
“Sure they had a teacher, but it wasn’t a regular teacher. It was a man.”
- ‘They’ refers to children who went to old schools hundreds of years ago
- ‘Regular’ means normal or usual – here it means mechanical teacher like Margie and Tommy have
- It is contrasted with human teacher who was a man
Short Paragraph Questions
What kind of teachers did Margie and Tommy have?
Margie and Tommy had mechanical teachers. These were large, black and ugly machines with big screens. The screen showed all lessons and asked questions. Students had to put homework and test papers in a slot. The mechanical teacher calculated marks immediately in no time. Each mechanical teacher was adjusted to fit mind of each student at their individual level.
Why did Margie’s mother send for the County Inspector?
Margie’s mother sent for County Inspector because Margie was doing badly in geography. The mechanical teacher had been giving her test after test in geography and she had been doing worse and worse. Her mother was worried and wanted Inspector to check if something was wrong with the mechanical teacher.
What did he do?
The County Inspector smiled at Margie and gave her an apple. Then he took the mechanical teacher apart with his box of tools with dials and wires. After examining it for about an hour, he put it back together. He found that geography sector was geared little too quick and slowed it down to average ten-year level. He patted Margie’s head and told her mother that overall pattern of her progress was quite satisfactory.
Why was Margie doing badly in geography? What did the County Inspector do to help her?
Margie was doing badly in geography because the geography sector of her mechanical teacher was geared little too quick for her level. The lessons were going faster than what a ten-year-old could handle. The County Inspector helped her by slowing down the geography sector to average ten-year level that was appropriate for her age and understanding.
What had once happened to Tommy’s teacher?
Tommy’s teacher had once been taken away for nearly a month. This happened because the history sector had blanked out completely. The mechanical teacher had stopped working properly and needed to be repaired. During this time, Tommy did not have to study history.
Did Margie have regular days and hours for school? If so, why?
Yes, Margie had regular days and hours for school. Her mechanical teacher was on and waiting for her at same time every day except Saturday and Sunday. Her mother insisted on this regular schedule because she believed that little girls learned better if they learned at regular hours. This helped maintain discipline and routine in studies.
How does Tommy describe the old kind of school?
Tommy describes old kind of school as a special building where all the kids from neighborhood went together. The children would come laughing and shouting in schoolyard, sit together in schoolroom, and go home together at end of day. All kids of same age learned same things, so they could help one another with homework and talk about it. It was completely different from studying alone at home with mechanical teacher.
How does he describe the old kind of teachers?
Tommy describes old kind of teachers as men (human beings) instead of machines. These teachers would tell boys and girls things, give them homework and ask them questions. They did not live in students’ houses but worked in special school building. All students learned same thing from these human teachers if they were of same age, unlike mechanical teachers that were adjusted differently for each student.
Long Answer Questions
What are the main features of the mechanical teachers and the schoolrooms that Margie and Tommy have in the story?
The mechanical teachers and schoolrooms in the story have several distinct features:
About Mechanical Teachers:
- They are large, black and ugly machines with big screens
- The screens display all lessons and ask questions
- They have slots where students insert homework and test papers
- Students write in punch code which they learn from age six
- The mechanical teacher calculates marks immediately
- Each teacher is adjusted to fit the mind of individual student
- They can be taken apart and repaired by County Inspector
- Different sectors (like geography, history) can be adjusted separately
- The speed of teaching can be slowed down or increased based on student’s level
About Schoolrooms:
- Each student has a schoolroom right next to their bedroom at home
- Students study alone without any classmates
- The mechanical teacher is always on at same time every day
- School days are all days except Saturday and Sunday
- Regular hours are maintained because it is believed students learn better with routine
- No interaction with other students or human teachers
- Everything is individual and isolated
Why did Margie hate school? Why did she think the old kind of school must have been fun?
Reasons Margie hated school:
- The mechanical teacher kept giving her test after test in geography
- She was doing worse and worse in these tests
- She found the mechanical teacher large, black and ugly
- She hated the slot where she had to put homework
- She had to write everything in punch code
- She had to study alone without any friends
- The teacher calculated marks immediately showing her poor performance
- There was no escape from regular hours
- She felt disappointed when Inspector repaired the teacher instead of taking it away
- The whole experience was lonely and mechanical
Why she thought old schools must have been fun:
- All kids from neighborhood came together to one building
- Children would be laughing and shouting in schoolyard
- They sat together in schoolroom with friends
- They went home together at end of day
- All children of same age learned same things
- They could help each other with homework
- They could talk about what they learned
- The teachers were real people, not machines
- There was human interaction and friendship
- Learning was social experience, not isolated one
- It seemed more enjoyable and less mechanical
Margie imagined how much kids must have loved it in old days. While her mechanical teacher flashed arithmetic problems on screen, she kept thinking about the fun they had in old schools with human teachers and friends to learn with.
Do you agree with Margie that schools today are more fun than the school in the story? Give reasons for your answer?
Yes, schools today are definitely more fun than the mechanical schools in the story for several reasons:
Social Interaction:
- Today we study with friends and classmates
- We can discuss, share ideas and help each other
- There are group activities and team projects
- We make lifelong friendships
- The story shows isolated learning which would be very lonely
Human Teachers:
- Our teachers are real people who understand emotions
- They can explain things in different ways if we don’t understand
- They motivate and inspire us
- They care about our overall development
- Mechanical teachers in story are just machines without feelings
Variety in Learning:
- We have different subjects, activities, sports and arts
- We go on field trips and excursions
- We have cultural programs and celebrations
- The story shows only mechanical learning on screen
School Environment:
- Our schools have playgrounds, libraries, laboratories
- We participate in sports and games
- We have lunch breaks to relax with friends
- Story shows only a room next to bedroom
Balanced Development:
- Today’s schools focus on physical, mental and emotional growth
- We learn social skills and values
- We develop personality through various activities
- Story’s mechanical teaching focuses only on academic performance
However, mechanical teachers have one advantage – they can adjust to individual student’s pace. But this single benefit cannot outweigh the joy of learning together with friends and real teachers who care about us.
Thinking about Language
Adverbs
An adverb describes action. We can form adverbs by adding -ly to adjectives.
Spelling Note: When adjective ends in -y, the y changes to i when we add -ly.
Example: angry → angrily
Making Adverbs from Adjectives:
| Adjective | Adverb |
|---|---|
| angry | angrily |
| happy | happily |
| merry | merrily |
| sleepy | sleepily |
| easy | easily |
| noisy | noisily |
| tidy | tidily |
| gloomy | gloomily |
Sentences from the story with adverbs:
- The pages were yellow and crinkly, and it was awfully funny to read words
- Her mother had shaken her head sorrowfully
- History sector had blanked out completely
- He added loftily, pronouncing the word carefully, “Centuries ago”
- We all behave differently when we are tired or hungry
- Tommy screamed with laughter nonchalantly
If Not and Unless
Unless means if not. Sentences with unless or if not are negative conditional sentences.
Structure:
- Condition part: uses present tense (with if not or unless)
- Result part: uses future tense (what will happen)
Examples:
- You’ll feel awful if you don’t finish your history lesson
- You’ll feel awful unless you finish your history lesson
More Examples:
| Future Tense | Condition (Present Tense) |
|---|---|
| There won’t be any books left | unless we preserve them |
| You won’t learn your lessons | unless you study regularly |
| Tommy will have an accident | unless he drives more slowly |
Completing Conditional Sentences:
- If I don’t go to Anu’s party tonight, she will be upset
- If you don’t telephone the hotel to order food, we won’t get dinner
- Unless you promise to write back, I won’t write to you
- If she doesn’t play any games, she won’t be healthy
- Unless that little bird flies away quickly, the cat will catch it
The Road Not Taken (Poem)
This poem by Robert Frost is about making choices and how choices shape our lives. The poet writes simply about common experiences.
The Poem
Stanza 1:
The traveller stands in yellow wood (forest in autumn) where two roads diverge (separate). He is sorry he cannot travel both roads. He stands there long time looking down one road as far as he could see to where it bent in undergrowth (dense growth of plants).
Stanza 2:
Then he took the other road, which was just as fair (equally good). It had perhaps better claim because it was grassy and wanted wear (had not been used much). Though actually the passing there had worn them really about same.
Stanza 3:
Both roads that morning equally lay in leaves no step had trodden black (no one had walked on fallen leaves). He kept first road for another day! But knowing how way leads on to way (one path leads to another), he doubted if he should ever come back.
Stanza 4:
He says he shall be telling this with a sigh somewhere ages and ages hence (in future). Two roads diverged in wood, and he took the one less travelled by. And that has made all the difference.
Thinking about the Poem
Where does the traveller find himself? What problem does he face?
- The traveller finds himself at a point where two roads diverge in yellow wood (forest)
- His problem is that he cannot travel both roads at once
- He must choose one path and leave the other
- This represents difficult choices we face in life
What these phrases mean:
| Phrase | Meaning |
|---|---|
| a yellow wood | Forest in autumn with yellow leaves falling |
| it was grassy and wanted wear | Road was grassy because not many people had walked on it |
| the passing there | People passing or walking on that road |
| leaves no step had trodden black | Fallen leaves that nobody had stepped on and made black |
| how way leads on to way | How one path leads to another, making it hard to return |
Is there any difference between the two roads?
- In stanzas two and three, poet says both roads were really about same, equally worn
- In last two lines, he says he took the one less travelled by
- This suggests he now sees them differently in memory than they actually were
- Memory and time have changed his perception
What do the last two lines mean?
- The poet accepts his choice rather than regrets it
- He believes the road he chose (even if not really less travelled) has shaped his life
- The choice has made all the difference in who he became
- It shows how we justify our choices and give them meaning later
- The sigh could be of satisfaction or slight regret, but he accepts what happened
Questions for Reflection:
Have you ever had to make difficult choice?
This asks students to think about their own experiences with choices – like which school to attend, which subjects to study, which friends to spend time with, how to spend free time. The reasons for choices vary – sometimes based on interest, sometimes on practical considerations, sometimes on advice from elders.
After making choice, do you think about what might have been?
Some people keep thinking about the road not taken – what if they had chosen differently? Others accept reality and move forward. Both approaches are natural. The poem suggests that while we may wonder, we should accept our choices because they have shaped who we are.
This chapter teaches us about comparing different ways of learning, understanding technological changes, and making choices in life. The story makes us appreciate the value of human interaction in education while the poem reminds us that our choices define our journey.
The Fun They Had – Complete Notes
This is a science fiction story set in the year 2157 that shows us how schools might be in future with computers playing major role in education. The story talks about children who will study through mechanical teachers and compares it with old traditional schools.
Before You Read
The story is set in future when books and schools as we know them might not exist anymore. Children will study through different means:
- Learning through computers – Students will use computer-based learning systems instead of traditional methods
- Virtual classroom – Not real classroom but learning happens through computer software or Internet
- Robotic teacher – Mechanical teachers that can adjust to each student’s level
- Moving e-text – Text that moves on screen instead of staying still on paper
Virtual reality means a reality created by computer software. Children today may already know about robots and can imagine what robotic teachers would be like.
The Story
Introduction – Finding the Old Book
On 17 May 2157, Margie wrote in her diary about an important discovery – Tommy had found a real book! This book was very old. Margie’s grandfather once said that when he was a little boy, his grandfather told him there was a time when all stories were printed on paper.
The children looked at the book with curiosity:
- The pages were yellow and crinkly
- The words stood still on the page instead of moving like they were supposed to on screen
- When they turned back to previous page, it had same words as before
Tommy found the book quite wasteful. He said when you finish with book, you just throw it away. But their television screen had million books on it and was good for plenty more. He wouldn’t throw away his screen.
Margie was eleven years old and hadn’t seen as many telebooks as Tommy, who was thirteen. She asked him where he found it. Tommy said he found it in his house, in the attic, without looking up because he was busy reading.
When Margie asked what the book was about, Tommy answered “School.”
Margie’s Hatred for School
Margie was scornful when she heard it was about school. She asked “School? What’s there to write about school? I hate school.”
Margie always hated school, but now she hated it more than ever because:
- The mechanical teacher had been giving her test after test in geography
- She had been doing worse and worse in the tests
- Her mother had shaken her head sorrowfully and sent for County Inspector
The County Inspector was a round little man with red face and whole box of tools with dials and wires. He smiled at Margie, gave her an apple, then took the teacher apart.
Margie had hoped he wouldn’t know how to put it together again, but he knew how all right. After an hour or so, there it was again – large and black and ugly, with big screen showing all lessons and asking questions.
The Mechanical Teacher
The part Margie hated most about her mechanical teacher was the slot where she had to put homework and test papers. She always had to write them in punch code they made her learn when she was six years old. The mechanical teacher calculated marks in no time.
After finishing inspection, the Inspector smiled and patted Margie’s head. He told her mother:
- It’s not little girl’s fault
- Geography sector was geared little too quick
- These things happen sometimes
- He has slowed it up to average ten-year level
- Overall pattern of her progress is quite satisfactory
Margie was disappointed because she had been hoping they would take teacher away altogether. They had once taken Tommy’s teacher away for nearly a month because history sector had blanked out completely.
Discussion About Old Schools
Margie asked Tommy why anyone would write about school. Tommy looked at her with very superior eyes and explained it’s not their kind of school. This is old kind of school they had hundreds and hundreds of years ago – centuries ago, he added loftily.
Margie was hurt and said she doesn’t know what kind of school they had all that time ago. She read book over his shoulder for a while and said “Anyway, they had a teacher.”
Key differences about old schools:
| Aspect | Old Schools | Future Schools (Margie’s time) |
|---|---|---|
| Teacher | Human being (a man) | Mechanical teacher |
| Location | Special building where all kids went | Right next to bedroom at home |
| Classmates | All kids from neighborhood together | Each child studied alone |
| Lessons | Same for all kids of same age | Adjusted for each child’s level |
| Homework | Given by human teacher | Put in slot for mechanical teacher |
Tommy explained that in old schools:
- The teacher was a man who told boys and girls things
- Gave them homework and asked questions
- Teachers didn’t live in the house
- They had special building and all kids went there
- All kids learned same thing if they were same age
Margie’s mother had told her that teacher has to be adjusted to fit mind of each boy and girl it teaches and each kid has to be taught differently. But Tommy said they didn’t do it that way in old times.
Margie’s School Routine
Margie’s mother called “Margie! School!” but Margie looked up and said “Not yet, Mamma.” Her mother insisted “Now!” and said it’s probably time for Tommy too.
Margie asked Tommy if she could read book some more with him after school. He said “May be” nonchalantly and walked away whistling, with dusty old book tucked beneath his arm.
Margie went into the schoolroom which was right next to her bedroom. The mechanical teacher was on and waiting for her. It was always on at same time every day except Saturday and Sunday, because her mother said little girls learned better if they learned at regular hours.
The screen was lit up with today’s lesson:
“Today’s arithmetic lesson is on addition of proper fractions. Please insert yesterday’s homework in proper slot.”
Missing the Old Days
Margie did her work with a sigh. She was thinking about old schools they had when her grandfather’s grandfather was a little boy:
- All kids from whole neighborhood came together
- Laughing and shouting in schoolyard
- Sitting together in schoolroom
- Going home together at end of day
- They learned same things, so they could help one another with homework and talk about it
- The teachers were people
The mechanical teacher was flashing on screen: “When we add fractions ½ and ¼…”
But Margie was thinking about how kids must have loved it in old days. She was thinking about the fun they had.
Thinking about the Text
Short Answer Questions
How old are Margie and Tommy?
- Margie was eleven years old
- Tommy was thirteen years old
What did Margie write in her diary?
- On page headed 17 May 2157, she wrote “Today Tommy found a real book!”
Had Margie ever seen a book before?
- No, Margie had never seen a real printed book before
- She had only seen telebooks on television screen
What things about the book did she find strange?
- The pages were yellow and crinkly
- Words stood still instead of moving like on screen
- When they turned back to previous page, it had same words as before
- It seemed wasteful because you throw it away when finished
What do you think a telebook is?
- A telebook is a book that appears on television or computer screen
- It has moving text instead of still printed words
- One screen can have million books stored on it
- It doesn’t need to be thrown away after reading
Where was Margie’s school? Did she have any classmates?
- Margie’s school was right next to her bedroom in her own house
- No, she did not have any classmates
- She studied alone with her mechanical teacher
What subjects did Margie and Tommy learn?
- Margie learned geography and arithmetic
- Tommy learned history
- They studied through their mechanical teachers
Reference to Context Questions
“I wouldn’t throw it away.”
- Tommy says these words
- ‘It’ refers to television screen that has telebooks
- It is being compared with old printed book that gets thrown away after reading
“Sure they had a teacher, but it wasn’t a regular teacher. It was a man.”
- ‘They’ refers to children who went to old schools hundreds of years ago
- ‘Regular’ means normal or usual – here it means mechanical teacher like Margie and Tommy have
- It is contrasted with human teacher who was a man
Short Paragraph Questions
What kind of teachers did Margie and Tommy have?
Margie and Tommy had mechanical teachers. These were large, black and ugly machines with big screens. The screen showed all lessons and asked questions. Students had to put homework and test papers in a slot. The mechanical teacher calculated marks immediately in no time. Each mechanical teacher was adjusted to fit mind of each student at their individual level.
Why did Margie’s mother send for the County Inspector?
Margie’s mother sent for County Inspector because Margie was doing badly in geography. The mechanical teacher had been giving her test after test in geography and she had been doing worse and worse. Her mother was worried and wanted Inspector to check if something was wrong with the mechanical teacher.
What did he do?
The County Inspector smiled at Margie and gave her an apple. Then he took the mechanical teacher apart with his box of tools with dials and wires. After examining it for about an hour, he put it back together. He found that geography sector was geared little too quick and slowed it down to average ten-year level. He patted Margie’s head and told her mother that overall pattern of her progress was quite satisfactory.
Why was Margie doing badly in geography? What did the County Inspector do to help her?
Margie was doing badly in geography because the geography sector of her mechanical teacher was geared little too quick for her level. The lessons were going faster than what a ten-year-old could handle. The County Inspector helped her by slowing down the geography sector to average ten-year level that was appropriate for her age and understanding.
What had once happened to Tommy’s teacher?
Tommy’s teacher had once been taken away for nearly a month. This happened because the history sector had blanked out completely. The mechanical teacher had stopped working properly and needed to be repaired. During this time, Tommy did not have to study history.
Did Margie have regular days and hours for school? If so, why?
Yes, Margie had regular days and hours for school. Her mechanical teacher was on and waiting for her at same time every day except Saturday and Sunday. Her mother insisted on this regular schedule because she believed that little girls learned better if they learned at regular hours. This helped maintain discipline and routine in studies.
How does Tommy describe the old kind of school?
Tommy describes old kind of school as a special building where all the kids from neighborhood went together. The children would come laughing and shouting in schoolyard, sit together in schoolroom, and go home together at end of day. All kids of same age learned same things, so they could help one another with homework and talk about it. It was completely different from studying alone at home with mechanical teacher.
How does he describe the old kind of teachers?
Tommy describes old kind of teachers as men (human beings) instead of machines. These teachers would tell boys and girls things, give them homework and ask them questions. They did not live in students’ houses but worked in special school building. All students learned same thing from these human teachers if they were of same age, unlike mechanical teachers that were adjusted differently for each student.
Long Answer Questions
What are the main features of the mechanical teachers and the schoolrooms that Margie and Tommy have in the story?
The mechanical teachers and schoolrooms in the story have several distinct features:
About Mechanical Teachers:
- They are large, black and ugly machines with big screens
- The screens display all lessons and ask questions
- They have slots where students insert homework and test papers
- Students write in punch code which they learn from age six
- The mechanical teacher calculates marks immediately
- Each teacher is adjusted to fit the mind of individual student
- They can be taken apart and repaired by County Inspector
- Different sectors (like geography, history) can be adjusted separately
- The speed of teaching can be slowed down or increased based on student’s level
About Schoolrooms:
- Each student has a schoolroom right next to their bedroom at home
- Students study alone without any classmates
- The mechanical teacher is always on at same time every day
- School days are all days except Saturday and Sunday
- Regular hours are maintained because it is believed students learn better with routine
- No interaction with other students or human teachers
- Everything is individual and isolated
Why did Margie hate school? Why did she think the old kind of school must have been fun?
Reasons Margie hated school:
- The mechanical teacher kept giving her test after test in geography
- She was doing worse and worse in these tests
- She found the mechanical teacher large, black and ugly
- She hated the slot where she had to put homework
- She had to write everything in punch code
- She had to study alone without any friends
- The teacher calculated marks immediately showing her poor performance
- There was no escape from regular hours
- She felt disappointed when Inspector repaired the teacher instead of taking it away
- The whole experience was lonely and mechanical
Why she thought old schools must have been fun:
- All kids from neighborhood came together to one building
- Children would be laughing and shouting in schoolyard
- They sat together in schoolroom with friends
- They went home together at end of day
- All children of same age learned same things
- They could help each other with homework
- They could talk about what they learned
- The teachers were real people, not machines
- There was human interaction and friendship
- Learning was social experience, not isolated one
- It seemed more enjoyable and less mechanical
Margie imagined how much kids must have loved it in old days. While her mechanical teacher flashed arithmetic problems on screen, she kept thinking about the fun they had in old schools with human teachers and friends to learn with.
Do you agree with Margie that schools today are more fun than the school in the story? Give reasons for your answer?
Yes, schools today are definitely more fun than the mechanical schools in the story for several reasons:
Social Interaction:
- Today we study with friends and classmates
- We can discuss, share ideas and help each other
- There are group activities and team projects
- We make lifelong friendships
- The story shows isolated learning which would be very lonely
Human Teachers:
- Our teachers are real people who understand emotions
- They can explain things in different ways if we don’t understand
- They motivate and inspire us
- They care about our overall development
- Mechanical teachers in story are just machines without feelings
Variety in Learning:
- We have different subjects, activities, sports and arts
- We go on field trips and excursions
- We have cultural programs and celebrations
- The story shows only mechanical learning on screen
School Environment:
- Our schools have playgrounds, libraries, laboratories
- We participate in sports and games
- We have lunch breaks to relax with friends
- Story shows only a room next to bedroom
Balanced Development:
- Today’s schools focus on physical, mental and emotional growth
- We learn social skills and values
- We develop personality through various activities
- Story’s mechanical teaching focuses only on academic performance
However, mechanical teachers have one advantage – they can adjust to individual student’s pace. But this single benefit cannot outweigh the joy of learning together with friends and real teachers who care about us.
Thinking about Language
Adverbs
An adverb describes action. We can form adverbs by adding -ly to adjectives.
Spelling Note: When adjective ends in -y, the y changes to i when we add -ly.
Example: angry → angrily
Making Adverbs from Adjectives:
| Adjective | Adverb |
|---|---|
| angry | angrily |
| happy | happily |
| merry | merrily |
| sleepy | sleepily |
| easy | easily |
| noisy | noisily |
| tidy | tidily |
| gloomy | gloomily |
Sentences from the story with adverbs:
- The pages were yellow and crinkly, and it was awfully funny to read words
- Her mother had shaken her head sorrowfully
- History sector had blanked out completely
- He added loftily, pronouncing the word carefully, “Centuries ago”
- We all behave differently when we are tired or hungry
- Tommy screamed with laughter nonchalantly
If Not and Unless
Unless means if not. Sentences with unless or if not are negative conditional sentences.
Structure:
- Condition part: uses present tense (with if not or unless)
- Result part: uses future tense (what will happen)
Examples:
- You’ll feel awful if you don’t finish your history lesson
- You’ll feel awful unless you finish your history lesson
More Examples:
| Future Tense | Condition (Present Tense) |
|---|---|
| There won’t be any books left | unless we preserve them |
| You won’t learn your lessons | unless you study regularly |
| Tommy will have an accident | unless he drives more slowly |
Completing Conditional Sentences:
- If I don’t go to Anu’s party tonight, she will be upset
- If you don’t telephone the hotel to order food, we won’t get dinner
- Unless you promise to write back, I won’t write to you
- If she doesn’t play any games, she won’t be healthy
- Unless that little bird flies away quickly, the cat will catch it
The Road Not Taken (Poem)
This poem by Robert Frost is about making choices and how choices shape our lives. The poet writes simply about common experiences.
The Poem
Stanza 1:
The traveller stands in yellow wood (forest in autumn) where two roads diverge (separate). He is sorry he cannot travel both roads. He stands there long time looking down one road as far as he could see to where it bent in undergrowth (dense growth of plants).
Stanza 2:
Then he took the other road, which was just as fair (equally good). It had perhaps better claim because it was grassy and wanted wear (had not been used much). Though actually the passing there had worn them really about same.
Stanza 3:
Both roads that morning equally lay in leaves no step had trodden black (no one had walked on fallen leaves). He kept first road for another day! But knowing how way leads on to way (one path leads to another), he doubted if he should ever come back.
Stanza 4:
He says he shall be telling this with a sigh somewhere ages and ages hence (in future). Two roads diverged in wood, and he took the one less travelled by. And that has made all the difference.
Thinking about the Poem
Where does the traveller find himself? What problem does he face?
- The traveller finds himself at a point where two roads diverge in yellow wood (forest)
- His problem is that he cannot travel both roads at once
- He must choose one path and leave the other
- This represents difficult choices we face in life
What these phrases mean:
| Phrase | Meaning |
|---|---|
| a yellow wood | Forest in autumn with yellow leaves falling |
| it was grassy and wanted wear | Road was grassy because not many people had walked on it |
| the passing there | People passing or walking on that road |
| leaves no step had trodden black | Fallen leaves that nobody had stepped on and made black |
| how way leads on to way | How one path leads to another, making it hard to return |
Is there any difference between the two roads?
- In stanzas two and three, poet says both roads were really about same, equally worn
- In last two lines, he says he took the one less travelled by
- This suggests he now sees them differently in memory than they actually were
- Memory and time have changed his perception
What do the last two lines mean?
- The poet accepts his choice rather than regrets it
- He believes the road he chose (even if not really less travelled) has shaped his life
- The choice has made all the difference in who he became
- It shows how we justify our choices and give them meaning later
- The sigh could be of satisfaction or slight regret, but he accepts what happened
Questions for Reflection:
Have you ever had to make difficult choice?
This asks students to think about their own experiences with choices – like which school to attend, which subjects to study, which friends to spend time with, how to spend free time. The reasons for choices vary – sometimes based on interest, sometimes on practical considerations, sometimes on advice from elders.
After making choice, do you think about what might have been?
Some people keep thinking about the road not taken – what if they had chosen differently? Others accept reality and move forward. Both approaches are natural. The poem suggests that while we may wonder, we should accept our choices because they have shaped who we are.
This chapter teaches us about comparing different ways of learning, understanding technological changes, and making choices in life. The story makes us appreciate the value of human interaction in education while the poem reminds us that our choices define our journey.
Download Free Mind Map from the link below
This mind map contains all important topics of this chapter
Visit our Class 9 English page for free mind maps of all Chapters